Goodfellas Pizzeria Reviews
Goodfellas Pizzeria has an overall rating of 4.4 based on 82 reviews. Customer feedback on Goodfellas Pizzeria is mixed: Goodfellas Pizzeria reviewers highlight positive aspects like delicious pizza, friendly staff, quick service and generous portions, which strongly appeal to families, pizza lovers, local residents. However, Goodfellas Pizzeria is often criticized for its inconsistent delivery times, limited parking, higher prices than competitors.
82 reviews
5 Stars
10
4 Stars
8
3 Stars
2
2 Stars
0
1 Star
0
How would you rate Goodfellas Pizzeria?
All Goodfellas Pizzeria Reviews (82)
WALKER
May 13, 2026
"Takeout held up really well"
Picked up a pizza and it was still hot by the time I got home, which was nice. The box didn’t get all soggy either, and the toppings actually stayed put. It’s one of those little things, or whatever that is, that just makes takeout feel way better.
0
Reply
hello_jonah782
May 09, 2026
"Really Quick Delivery"
I ordered on a Friday night and it showed up way faster than I expected. The pizza was still nice and hot, and the driver was totally fine. I’m taking off one star because the tracking was a little vague, but overall it was a good experience.
0
Reply
FloydMclellan_26
April 27, 2026
"Ordered delivery. Pizza showed up still hot, which…"
Ordered delivery. Pizza showed up still hot, which was great. Fries had cooled down a little by the time they got here. Still fine though. Overall, happy with it.
0
Reply
CliffordMcneese_01
April 09, 2026
"Pretty easy to find"
Goodfellas was in a convenient spot for us and not hard to get to at all. We were just there for a pickup, so I can’t really speak to everything, but getting in and out was simple enough. Parking was a little tight when it got busy, but overall it worked out fine
0
Reply
ValerieDeubner_35
April 08, 2026
"I went to Goodfellas Pizzeria with a..."
I went to Goodfellas Pizzeria with a friend and it was nice not having to wait for a table. There were plenty of seats, so we could just sit down, relax, and enjoy our food. It’s always a plus when a pizza place doesn’t feel too crowded. I’d definitely go back
0
Reply
bonnie_Threlkeld98
April 04, 2026
"The service was really, really friendly, which…"
The service was really, really friendly, which I appreciated. It just took a bit, a bit longer than I expected to get some help.
0
Reply
JohnPolkinghorn
April 02, 2026
"The place was clean. Tables got wiped…"
The place was clean. Tables got wiped down fast, which I always notice... and the bathroom was actually fine, not one of those gross ones you want to avoid
0
Reply
richardmoody5645
March 17, 2026
"The veggies tasted really fresh, and…"
The veggies tasted really fresh, and the dough was nice too. fresh toppings always make everything better, and this one definitely had that going for it.
0
Reply
Maureen.jackson
March 14, 2026
"Always a reliable pizza spot"
I’ve been here a few times now, and reading between the lines, there’s a reason I keep coming back. The pizza is consistently good every time, nothing flashy, just solid, dependable, and exactly what I’m hoping for when I stop in.
0
Reply
Rose-stover
March 08, 2026
"Great pizza for the price!"
I’ve ordered from Goodfellas Pizzeria a few times now it’s been really good every time :) The portions are properly generous, the pizza tastes fresh, and the prices don’t feel over the top like some places. We managed to get enough food for the whole family without spending loads, which is always a win! Nothing fancy or complicated, just solid, tasty pizza that’s definitely worth the money :)
0
Reply
denise_Kellems70
March 06, 2026
"The crust was crispy, the middle was nice..."
The crust was crispy, the middle was nice and chewy, and there was just something about it... I really loved it
0
Reply
tony1996
March 02, 2026
"I was able to find a spot..."
I was able to find a spot close by without too much hassle, which was nice. It only took a few minutes, so that made things easier. Something about it could be a little better though, I’d probably give 5 stars if the lot was a bit bigger.
0
Reply
RuthieMosley_41
February 26, 2026
"Easy hours to work around"
5 stars from me . Their hours are super convenient , especially when I’m running behind but still want to grab pizza without making it a whole thing . I checked the site before heading over and it was really easy to see when they were open . Way better than guessing or having to call around .
0
Reply
JamesBoltz_11
February 08, 2026
"Really Good Crust and Sauce"
I really enjoyed it. The crust was great, like seriously great, and the sauce had a nice flavor that made the whole thing taste even better.
0
Reply
james.Beddo
January 29, 2026
"Good food, but pickup was late"
The food was good, but I ended up waiting about 15 minutes past the pickup time they gave me. I get that places get busy, but it was still frustrating just standing around. Not the end of the world, but an apology or quick acknowledgment would’ve been appreciated.
0
Reply
FARMER
January 28, 2026
"Bigger slices than I thought"
The main thing I noticed was how big the slices were. I wasn’t really paying attention to much else at first because they were way bigger than I expected, which was a nice surprise.
0
Reply
WEBB
January 28, 2026
"Easy order, pickup was a little off"
Ordering was simple, but the pickup time ended up changing on me, and by the time I got the pizza it was a little colder than I expected. It still tasted good though, just not quite as good as...
0
Reply
Michael_graham71
December 19, 2025
"Decent menu, but nothing too exciting"
The menu has a fair mix of pizzas, sides, and a few other little bits, so it’s not bad 🙂 I just expected a bit more variety or maybe some more interesting toppings. It’s fine if you’re after the usual classics, but nothing really stood out to me...
0
Reply
Elton_fossett83
December 11, 2025
"Pretty Good Overall"
Everything was sorta just right, thanks! I had a good experience and really appreciate it.
0
Reply
RobynRalston
December 10, 2025
"Easygoing local pizza spot"
Pretty solid little pizza place, honestly. Nothing too fancy or overdone, just a chill spot where you can sit down, eat, and not feel rushed. The place had a nice easygoing feel to it, not loud or annoying, and the tables were clean. Staff seemed relaxed and friendly enough. Basically, if you want a comfy local pizza joint with decent vibes, this place does the job.
0
Reply
Have a question about Goodfellas Pizzeria?
Log in to ask your Goodfellas Pizzeria question!
Popular Brands
Customer Reviews
Ask a Question
